“Under the influence of the overall environment, there has been a shift in mindset among consumers in lower tier cities, with co-existing ‘compensation demands’ driving spending on self-pleasing, and ‘protection demands’ prompting investment in the future. There is also a simultaneous focus on the need for real consumer satisfaction offered by products themselves, and the need for a sense of identity brought by brands. Consumer behaviour is gradually becoming reserved, with consumers expecting more sincere and straightforward spending experiences while showing a distaste for cheap gimmicks. Brand values still hold their ground, but these need a more genuine approach when dealing with consumers in lower tier cities. Focusing on maintaining official channels can help brands provide more interactions and foster a sense of trust.”
– Frank Zhang, Senior Research Analyst
Key issues covered in this Report
- Changes in consumer psychology: living in the moment and safeguarding the future.
- Changes in the definition of ‘good value’: returning to the self and price anchoring.
- Filtering and judging information: being selectively influenced and simplifying decisions.
- Brand style and concepts: strengthening sense of identity and putting concepts into practice.
Collapse All
-
Overview
- What you need to know
- Key issues covered in this Report
- Objective and methodology
- Quantitative research methodology
- Figure 1: The sample structure for each city is as follows:
- Qualitative research methodology
- Figure 2: Interviewed cities in the qualitative research
- Figure 3: Profiles of respondents to the qualitative research
- What you need to know
-
Executive Summary
-
- The market
- Demands for sustainable development and differentiation emerge
- Figure 4: GDP sector compositions, by city tier, 2019-21
- Salary growth slows, and consumption momentum weakens
- Figure 5: Per capita annual salary, by city tier, 2019-21
- Figure 6: Total retail sales and year-on-year growth rate of consumer goods, by city tier, 2019-21
- Financial confidence continues to fluctuate
- Figure 7: Confidence in improving future finances, by city tier, 2020-23
- The consumer
- Changes in consumer psychology: living in the moment and safeguarding the future
- Figure 8: Behaviours of discretionary spending and investment, by age, 2023
- Changes in the definition of ‘good value’: returning to the self and price anchoring
- Figure 9: Selected ways of improving finances, by age, 2022
- Filtering and judging information: being selectively influenced and simplifying decisions
- Figure 10: Online purchase channels of personal care appliances, by age, 2023
- Brand style and concepts: strengthening sense of identity and putting concepts into practice
- Figure 11: Marketing strategies that increase consumer favourability towards smartphone brands, by age, 2023
- What we think
-
-
Introduction to Lower Tier Cities in China
-
- Demands for sustainable development and differentiation emerge
- Figure 12: GDP sector compositions, by city tier, 2019-21
- Salary growth slows, while consumption momentum weakens
- Figure 13: Per capita annual salary, by city tier, 2019-21
-
- Figure 14: Total retail sales and year-on-year growth rate of consumer goods, by city tier, 2019-21
- The pull effect of the metropolitan economy is expected
- Figure 15: Total domestic highway mileage, by city tier, 2020 and 2021
- The increase in flexible employment and work-on-the-go brings new opportunities for the development of low tier cities
- Figure 16: Type of employment, by city tier, 2020-23
-
- Figure 17: Company types, by city tier, 2020-23
-
-
Market Factors
- Financial confidence continues to fluctuate
- Figure 18: Confidence in improving future finances, by city tier, 2020-23
- Upgrading demand has declined and high-end consumption become more cautious
- Figure 19: Trading up and down, tier 3 or lower cities, Q1 2022 vs Q1 2023
-
- Figure 20: Trading up and down, tier 3 or lower cities, Q1 2022 vs Q1 2023
- Chain service brands tap into lower tier cities, driving the innovation and quality improvement of consumer experience
- Figure 21: Changes in the number of stores of Helen’s, Miniso and Haidilao in different cities, by city tier, 2021 vs 2022
- Figure 22: Convenience store shopping frequency – once a day or more, by city tier, 2019 vs 2023
- The influence of short videos has expanded, accelerating the conversion of traffic value to user value
- Figure 23: Changes in short video usage – every day, by city tier, H1 2021-H1 2023
- Domestic travel is recovering strongly, and the combination of local cultural tourism resources and commerce has attracted attention
- Figure 24: Mentions and engagement of ‘Zibo’ (淄博) on social media channels, January-June 2023
- Financial confidence continues to fluctuate
-
Interviews with Industry Experts
- Leverage the value-for-money advantage of small town model through store, equipment and menu adjustment
- Figure 25: Expert interviewees’ take on lower tier city market and consumer perceptions, 2023
- Focus on household consumption habits and the construction of logistics networks
- Figure 26: Expert interviewees’ take on lower tier city market and consumer perceptions, 2023
- Initiate conversations on consumption scenarios integrating regional features
- Figure 27: Expert interviewees’ take on consumption scenarios and marketing methods in lower tier city, 2023
- Explore ‘down-to-earth’ communication methods and channels
- Figure 28: Expert interviewees’ take on lower tier city market and consumer perceptions, 2023
- Leverage the value-for-money advantage of small town model through store, equipment and menu adjustment
-
Changes in Consumer Psychology: Living in the Moment and Safeguarding the Future
- Post-pandemic ‘compensation mentality’ drives spending on self-pleasing
-
- Figure 29: Trading up and willingness to self-reward with regard to travel – interview excerpts, 2023
-
- Figure 30: Trading up and willingness to self-reward with regard to staying at home – interview excerpts, 2023
-
- Figure 31: Trading up and willingness to self-reward with regard to skincare – interview excerpts, 2023
- Growing awareness of long-term investments in health and education
-
- Figure 32: Trading up and willingness to self-reward with regard to fitness and self-improvement – interview excerpts, 2023
-
- Figure 33: Spending on family – interview excerpts, 2023
-
- Figure 34: Trading down – interview excerpts, 2023
- Indulgent spending and protection-oriented investment both valued
-
- Figure 35: Behaviours of discretionary spending and investment, by age, 2023
- More pronounced demand for investing in tech devices for health among 30-39 year olds
-
- Figure 36: Reasons for using smart watch/wristband, by age, 2023
- Reopening and creating new plans to turn ideas into action
-
- Figure 37: Ctrip’s 318 Global Travel Bargain Festival, 2023
- Putting ‘invisible effort’ into lightening the health burden of foods
-
- Figure 38: Lay’s x Niao Niao ‘Invisible efforts – are they worth it?’, 2022
- Post-pandemic ‘compensation mentality’ drives spending on self-pleasing
-
Changes in the Definition of ‘Good Value’: Returning to the Self and Price Anchoring
- Shifting from external to self-defined notions of ‘good value’
- Figure 39: Changes in the definition of ‘good value’ – interview excerpts, 2023
- Figure 40: ‘Lower prices for the same product’ – interview excerpts, 2023
-
- Figure 41: ‘Cheaper alternatives’ – interview excerpts, 2023
- Becoming weary of big promotions, consumers look to sincere ‘no-gimmick’ marketing
- Figure 42: Big promotions – interview excerpts, 2023
- Discretionary spending control more accepted than ‘brand downgrading’
- Figure 43: Selected ways of improving finances, by age, 2022
- Practicality is fulfilment and conformity is safety, especially for older consumers
- Figure 44: Keywords in small kitchen appliance marketing content, by age, 2023
- Themed shopping festival at consumers’ doorstep focuses on affordability with ‘no gimmicks’
- Figure 45: Juhuasuan’s ‘Super Bargain Festival Half-price Art Exhibition’, 2023
- Inviting ‘down-to-earth people’ to give practical introductions of products’ selling points
- Figure 46: Luo Yonghao x NetEase Selected’s ‘What is a Good Thing?’, 2022
- Shifting from external to self-defined notions of ‘good value’
-
Filtering and Judging Information: Being Selectively Influenced and Simplifying Decisions
- Identifying practical information and increasing awareness of saving time and money
- Figure 47: Accessing information and making decisions about consumer goods – interview excerpts, 2023
- Figure 48: Changes in attitudes towards product recommendations – interview excerpts (more easily influenced by recommendations), 2023
-
- Figure 49: Changes in attitudes towards product recommendations – interview excerpts (less easily influenced by recommendations), 2023
- ‘Celebrity live streamers’ still effective in promoting lifestyle essentials
- Figure 50: Live stream shopping experiences – interview excerpts, 2023
- Figure 51: Favourite types of live streamers – interview excerpts, 2023
- Live streams’ emotional value and atmosphere more appealing to middle-aged people in lower tier cities
- Figure 52: Reasons for continuing to follow a live streamer, by age, 2023
- Consumers in lower tier cities buy more personal care appliances from Douyin than those in tier 1 and 2 cities
- Figure 53: Online purchase channels of personal care appliances, by age, 2023
- Popular live streams interact with celebrities to bring a sense of atmosphere
- Figure 54: Crazy Young Brother hosts shopping live streams with celebrities, 2023
- Gaining trust from local consumers through localised expressions
- Figure 55: Xiaohongshu’s ‘Chongqing people understand life, Xiaohongshu understands Chongqing people’, 2023
- Identifying practical information and increasing awareness of saving time and money
-
Brand Style and Concepts: Strengthening Sense of Identity and Putting Concepts into Practice
- Chinese style and environmental concepts are important sources of brand favourability
- Figure 56: Brand labels – interview excerpts, 2023
- Demand for brand values is low, and is mainly reflected in avoiding negativity
- Figure 57: Brand values – interview excerpts, 2023
- Brands promoting Chinese culture viewed more favourably by consumers in lower tier cities
- Figure 58: Marketing strategies that increase consumer favourability towards smartphone brands, by age, 2023
- Environmental concepts universally accepted, and middle-aged consumers more eager for eco-friendly materials
- Figure 59: Claims of sustainable brands, by age, 2023
- Breaking down antagonism and painting a picture of ‘Greater China’
- Figure 60: BYD’s ‘Together is what makes Chinese cars’, 2023
- Experiencing implementation of environmental concepts from a first-person perspective
- Figure 61: Anta’s ‘Mountain and River Project’, 2023
- Chinese style and environmental concepts are important sources of brand favourability
-
Appendix
- Abbreviations
- Abbreviations
Why Choose Mintel?
Mintel is the world’s leading market intelligence agency. We show you how consumers think today and tomorrow. As a trusted partner to industry leaders, we deliver game-changing insights to businesses across the globe, fuelling their marketing and innovation strategies that will shape the future.
Access high-quality market research with every purchase of Mintel’s consumer reports. Here’s what else is included in your report purchase:
- Multiple Report Formats: Mintel’s reports are available in PDF and PPT formats, and are delivered straight to your inbox, so you can easily share Mintel’s market intelligence.
- Access to Mintel’s Clients Portal: After your purchase is completed, you’ll receive an invitation to join Mintel’s Clients Portal, providing instant access to supplementary insights from Mintel’s industry experts.
- Interactive Databook: Mintel’s bespoke consumer data is presented as an interactive website, so you can deep dive into your chosen topic, explore demographics and download specific statistics.
- Custom Presentation Tool: Easily incorporate selected research data and analysis into a tailor-made presentation to win over clients and stakeholders.
£ 3,695 (Excl.Tax)
-
Download today with instant access
Pay via credit card or invoice (net 30 payment terms)
-
Multiple formats provided
We send a PDF, Powerpoint and Excel Databook straight to your inbox. An interactive version of the report is also available on our online platform
-
Interactive databook included
Focus on the data that matters most to you with a customisable databook avaliable on our platform
-
Save up to 20% when you purchase multiple reports
Discount automatically applied in basket
Next Starts Here
Whatever your business needs, we have the solution. From market intelligence reports to customised growth strategies.
Learn moreTrusted by global industry leaders
At Jackman, we believe that powerful strategies are based on human insight. Mintel’s leading-edge reports and insights into consumer attitudes and behaviors are an important input as we develop and execute strategy.
Alana Gavin, VP Research and Insights, Jackman
We utilize Mintel Reports, Trends and Comperemedia to mine for insights across the numerous business verticals that Epsilon serves, such as CPG, automotive, telecom, healthcare/pharma, retail and financial services.
By integrating Mintel insight into new business opportunities, we have been able to gain the competitive edge necessary to advance partnerships with global brands and key business players.
For our organization, it’s about depth and breadth. Having one without the other doesn’t enable success in our business.
Virginia Harvey, Secondary Research Manager, Epsilon
Working in a customer-obsessed organization means that data and insights have to be at our fingertips. Mintel’s reports help us support anecdotes with real quantifiable insights. The summary sections (which I really like) helps save time by giving a birds eye view of the content before spending time combing through the pages.
Our business review discussions are strengthened by the relevancy of the reports to help us better understand our customers. In addition, the customer service received from the team (especially in crunch periods) makes the process of understanding customer behavior even better.
Ngozi Ngonadi-Nkwoji, Senior Marketing Manager, Amazon
There is no question that Mintel is the go-to resource for the best quality market research, but I did not think it was an affordable option for Abacus Marketing to consider. As a small marketing agency, we only work with a few new clients each year.
However, we have a very high-end consultative approach to our work, so we really do need a partner like Mintel to provide the big agency experience we are always aiming to deliver. Our clients come from an incredibly diverse range of industry sectors, so we obviously need access to market research reports from a very wide spectrum of marketplaces – and that is precisely what we got.
Stephen Taylor-Brown, Managing Director, Abacus
Mintel is really good for getting a handle on a particular category quickly. If we are working on a new business pitch in an area we don’t have much experience in, it’s a brilliant way to get up to speed with what’s going on, what’s changing and what the key trends are in any category.
It’s very rare now that anyone will plough through a 200-page report – that’s why the summaries are really useful. We know they are backed up by a lot of detail, so if you need to go into something in more depth you know the information will be all there for you.
Pauline Robson, Managing Partner, Mediacom
Next Starts Here
Whatever your business needs, we have the solution. From market intelligence reports to customised growth strategies.
Learn more
